The Big AI Secret. Chapter 2 Summary: Breaking through the complexity Barrier 🤫
By Polly Barnfield, OBE, CEO of Maybe*
When More AI Tools Mean Less Productivity
Here's a pattern we see repeatedly: marketing teams start with one AI tool. It works well. They add another. Still good. Then another. And another. Before long, they're managing 15+ AI tools, and nobody can remember why they subscribed to half of them.
Sound familiar?
68% of organisations admit their AI stack grew faster than their ability to manage it. However, here's the counterintuitive insight that changes everything: companies that reduced their tool count by 30% or more while increasing integration saw a 45% ROI improvement within six months.
Less is more. Integration beats innovation. Everytime.
The Complexity Trap
Marketing agencies are particularly vulnerable to AI tool sprawl. New tools launch weekly. Each promises to be a game-changer. Your competitors are adopting them. FOMO sets in.
So you add:
A content generation tool
A social media AI assistant
An email optimisation platform
A predictive analytics dashboard
A chatbot builder
Another content tool (because the first one doesn't do video)
Within months, you're drowning in:
Multiple login credentials (and password resets)
Disconnected data that can't flow between systems
Duplicate capabilities you're paying for twice
Training debt as team members struggle to keep up
Integration nightmares when you try to make tools work together
The result? AI increases workloads for 61% of marketers instead of reducing them.
Why Simplification Beats Innovation
High-performing organisations follow a different playbook. They understand that strategic simplification drives better results than constant accumulation.
The data proves it:
Companies with fewer, deeply integrated tools see 45% better ROI
Teams that consolidate redundant tools report 3.2× less operational friction
Organisations that platform-think outperform those that tool-collect
What High-Performers Do Differently
1. They Conduct Regular Stack Audits
Every quarter, top-performing teams ask:
Which tools are actually being used?
Which deliver measurable ROI?
Which overlap in functionality?
Which could be consolidated or replaced?
2. They Think Platforms, Not Point Solutions
Instead of adopting 10 specialised tools, they choose solutions that solve multiple use cases. One integrated platform beats five disconnected point solutions.
3. They Apply the 10-Tool Threshold
Our research identifies a critical tipping point: once teams exceed 10 disconnected tools, waste accelerates exponentially.
0-5 tools: High experimentation, minimal waste
6-10 tools: Integration becomes critical
10-15 tools: Waste accelerates without consolidation
15+ tools: Costs spiral without a clear strategy
Each disconnected tool beyond 10 costs an average of £18,000-£32,000 annually in wasted effort and overlap.
4. They Prioritise Integration Capabilities
Before adopting any new tool, they ask:
Does it integrate with our existing stack?
Can data flow automatically between systems?
Will it reduce manual handoffs or create more?
The Simplification Roadmap
Week 1-2: Audit Your Current Stack
List every AI tool your team uses
Document who uses what, how often, and for what purpose
Calculate total monthly/annual costs
Identify overlapping capabilities
Week 3-4: Analyse Integration Gaps
Map how data flows (or doesn't) between tools
Identify manual handoffs and context-switching points
Calculate the time wasted on bridging systems
Prioritise highest-impact integration opportunities
Week 5-8: Consolidate and Connect
Eliminate redundant subscriptions
Replace multiple point solutions with integrated platforms where possible
Implement API connections or integration tools (like Zapier) for the remaining tools
Standardise on fewer, more powerful solutions
Week 9-12: Measure and Optimise
Track time saved per workflow
Measure the reduction in manual handoffs
Calculate ROI improvement
Train team on simplified, integrated stack
The ROI Reality
Companies following this simplification approach typically see:
45% ROI improvement within 6 months
30-40% reduction in tool-related costs
2-3 hours saved per person per week from reduced context switching
60% higher confidence in using AI tools
The Bottom Line
Your AI stack should amplify your team's capabilities, not complicate them.
If your team is managing 12+ tools, you don't have an innovation problem. You have an integration problem. And the solution isn't adding another tool it's simplifying and connecting what you already have.
The companies winning with AI aren't the ones with the most tools. They're the ones with the most integrated tools.
This blog is based on research from Maybe's whitepaper, "The Big AI Secret," which features interviews with over 1,000 senior business leaders and is cross-validated against the Stanford HAI AI Index 2025, the McKinsey State of AI Survey 2025, and the BCG AI at Work Report 2025.
Next in this series: Blog 3 examines why C-suite adoption is the #1 predictor of AI success, and how leadership drives integration.
Learn more about AI Agents.
